Finding the right eyeshadow color for your eyes enhances your natural beauty, making your eyes pop.
I’ve lost count of how many times in the past I’ve purchased the wrong shade for my brown eyes – not just a waste of money, but also lost time spent having to redo my makeup because it just doesn’t look good.
Fortunately, I’ve now discovered some staple shades that are flattering and of great quality.
In this guide, you’ll find:
- The very best MAC eyeshadows for brown and hazel eyes
- The varying types of MAC shadow formulas
- Eyeshadow shades you should avoid if you have brown or hazel eyes
- Best MAC eyeshadows for green eyes
- 10 best MAC eyeshadows for blue eyes
- 18 best MAC lipsticks for pale skin
- The best Colourpop eyeshadow palettes for brown and hazel eyes
- How to start a makeup collection for beginners
Best MAC Eyeshadows for Brown and Hazel Eyes
Whether you’re looking for a subtle daytime look or are heading out on the town for a glam evening, I’ve got you covered.
First, let’s take a look at some of the different types of MAC eyeshadow shades for brown eyes and hazel-eyed people.
Why MAC eyeshadows?
As a makeup enthusiast, it’s important to only use quality eyeshadow products, and that’s what you get with MAC.
Their eyeshadows are known for their pigmentation, blendability, and long-lasting wear, although some shades do perform better than others.
MAC carries varying types of eyeshadows:
- Single eyeshadow pans and shadows – matte, satin, frost, veluxe pearl, lustre
- MAC eyeshadow palettes and quads
- Dazzleshadow – cream texture with a 3d glitter effect
- Dazzleshadow extreme – molten metallic finish shadow
- Dazzleshadow liquid – liquid shadow with a metallic or glitter finish
- Pro longwear paint pot – long lasting cream shadow
- Extra dimension eyeshadow – these tend to be in limited edition collections
- Pigment – loose concentrated powder formula
The Best MAC Eyeshadows for Brown and Hazel eyes
What eyeshadow looks best on brown eyes? Is there a color that looks best on hazel eyes?
Here are some of the most flattering shades for brown and hazel eyes. I’ve separated these into different skin color types, although some of the best MAC eyeshadows are universally flattering.
Best mac eyeshadow for brown eyes and fair skin
When choosing eyeshadow for brown eyes and fair skin, there are several options that can complement your features.
Depending on the overall look you want to go for, you may want to use them as a wash of color or pair them with other shadows for extra depth and definition.
This is a soft, golden-beige with a slight shimmer and frost finish. It adds a warm glow to the eyes and works well on both fair and olive skin tones.
You can easily use this shade as a wash of color over the eyes or use with darker tones for a jewel-toned glam look.
Woodwinked is a warm bronze shade with a metallic finish. It brings out the richness and depth of brown eyes, while also adding warmth to fair skin. It’s an iconic MAC shade and is a great eyeshadow for both day and night.
A taupe shade with a subtle shimmer, this is the creme de la creme of quality in terms of MAC. If you purchase any MAC shadow, then make it this one.
Satin taupe has cool undertones that complement both brown eyes and fair skin, creating a sophisticated and neutral look. Again, this is another shade that looks good for day and night.
This matte, medium-brown shade works well for adding depth to the crease and outer corner of the eyes. It creates definition and enhances the natural color of brown eyes.
Swiss Chocolate can also be used wet as a liner – it’s ideal for pairing with lighter shades, such as omega or brule.
Amber Lights is a vibrant, shimmery copper shade, adding a beautiful warm contrast to fair skin tones. It also looks gorgeous on hazel eyes too.
The best mac green eyeshadow for brown eyes has to be humid – this pigmented green has a frost finish, perfect for an evening look, or to pair with neutral tones for casual day makeup.
If you prefer a wet looking eyeshadow, I recommend MAC Dazzleshadow Extreme in Joie De Glitz which is a gorgeous olive green shade.
Best mac eyeshadow for brown eyes and olive skin
For brown eyes and olive skin, there are brilliant MAC eyeshadows that enhance your features.
This rich reddish-brown shade with a shimmer finish enhances the warmth of brown eyes and complements olive undertones in the skin. If you want to create a sultry and captivating look, this is the perfect shadow.
A warm, medium-brown matte shade, Saddle is the ideal transition color in the crease as it adds depth to the eyes without overpowering them.
Coquette is an underrated MAC shadow, and a medium to dark taupe brown with a matte finish. This shade looks good paired with other neutral tones, or even used on the brows.
Best mac eyeshadow for brown eyes and dark skin
For brown eyes and dark skin, there are some stunning MAC shades that’ll look amazing on you.
This vibrant orange copper shade with a shimmer finish complements the warm undertones in dark skin and brings out the richness of brown eyes. If you’re thinking of creating a striking and eye-catching look, this is one for your must-have list.
This gorgeous cobalt blue with a satin finish contrasts beautifully with brown eyes and adds a touch of drama to dark skin tones.
Sketch is a deep burgundy shade with red shimmer. It’s perfect for adding richness and dimension to the eyes, especially on darker skin tones.
Best mac eyeshadow colors for hazel eyes
Hazel eyes have a unique blend of colors, often including tones of brown, green, and gold.
If you’re looking to enhance and bring out the hues in your hazel eyes, here are some MAC eyeshadow colors that work well.
MAC Steamy is a cool toned teal and frost finish. It looks striking with hazel eyes, especially when paired with brown or taupe tones.
Mulch is a brown hue with bronze pearl. It complements the gold and brown tones in hazel eyes and adds warmth and depth to your overall eye makeup. Another underrated MAC addition.
Other notable mentions
Worst eyeshadow colors for brown eyes
You may be wondering if there are any bad eyeshadow shades for brown eyes?
While there are no rules about what eyeshadow colors you should avoid, there are some hues that are less flattering than others.
Here are some shades that you may want to avoid or try out with caution.
- Light pastels. Very light pastel shades like baby blue or pale pink can make brown eyes appear dull or washed out. If you want to experiment with these types of shades, consider using them sparingly.
- Cool-toned greys. Cool-toned grey shades can sometimes clash with the warmth of brown eyes and make them appear less vibrant. However, this does depend on the undertones of the grey eyeshadow you’re using and your individual skin tone.
- Ashy browns. Brown eyeshadows with ashy undertones that are too similar to the natural color of brown eyes may not offer enough contrast, making the eyes appear less defined.
Remember that makeup is an art form, and rules can be broken. So, feel free to experiment and explore different eyeshadow colors to find what works best for you and makes you feel confident.
Try These Best MAC Eyeshadows for Brown and Hazel Eyes Today!
MAC offers some beautiful shades for all eye colors so finding the best MAC eyeshadows for brown and hazel eyes should be easy.
While the suggestions in this guide are a great starting point, personal preference, and experimentation are key. Everyone’s eyes are unique, and what works for one person may differ for another.
Don’t be afraid to step outside these recommendations and explore different colors that make you feel creative. After all, it’s good to embrace your individuality, and have fun with your eyeshadow choices!