The OG Urban Decay Setting Spray called Urban Decay All Nighter is one of the most well-known setting sprays on the market, gaining a cult following in the beauty community.
Used by makeup artists and beauty lovers alike, this spray locks in your makeup, preventing it from smudging, fading, or melting throughout the day, even in humid weather conditions.
I personally love using this spray to keep my makeup looking fresh, especially when my complexion gets oily during the warmer months.
It sounds like magic, but the patented temperature-controlled technology within the formulation lowers the temperature of your makeup to stop it from sliding off your face.
Another reason why this setting spray is so popular is the vegan and cruelty-free formula…
In fact, the only downside is the price for the various Urban Decay setting spray sizes.
It costs $36/£28 for a 118ml full size bottle of Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray, $16/£15 for a 30ml travel size bottle, and £10 for a 15ml mini bottle.
The good news is that if you’re looking for an affordable alternative to the Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray, I’ve got more than one Urban Decay All nighter setting spray dupes to show you.
There are several dupes on the market that claim to provide the same long-lasting hold without breaking the bank. But do they really live up to the hype?
Let’s have a look at 13 of the best Urban Decay setting spray dupes below.
Urban Decay Setting Spray Dupes
When looking for a dupe, it’s important to keep in mind that not all dupes are created equal.
Some dupes have a slightly different formula or finish, while others may not be quite as long-lasting.
However, the best dupes that I’ve found perform very closely to the original Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray.
Is Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray waterproof?
Yes, the Urban Decay All Nighter is waterproof so it protects your makeup if you go for a swim or are outside in the rain.
Can All Nighter be used as a primer?
Yes, All Nighter can be used as a primer by spraying it onto moisturized skin. However, I recommend using a mattifying primer rather than a setting spray as it’ll be gentler on your skin.
How long does Urban Decay Setting Spray last?
It lasts for up to 16 hours.
Does Urban Decay setting spray really work?
Yes, and according to Urban Decay, 1 bottle of All Nighter is sold every 11 seconds in the US. While it’s well worth buying, there are plenty of dupes to consider.
Ingredients in All Nighter Setting Spray
To narrow down the perfect dupe of All Nighter Setting Spray, it’s important to look at its ingredients. All Nighter provides a matte finish on the complexion, and contains the following ingredients:
Alcohol Denat – Urban Decay All Nighter is alcohol based to help your makeup stay in place. This is what makes it ideal for oily or combination skin types.
Aloe Vera – Aloe vera has soothing properties to help calm irritated skin and keep your makeup looking fresh all day.
Fragrance – Urban Decay Setting Spray does contain perfume which may be another reason to find a good dupe since many people find fragrance irritating on their skin.
Popular Urban Decay All Nighter Alternatives
So, what is an alternative to the All Nighter?
Here are some of the best, and most popular dupes, for the Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray.
Best Ingredients Dupe:
The Skindinavia Finishing Spray also contains cooling technology similar to the Urban Decay setting spray and ingrdients that are close to the original.
Priced $29/£24 for 118ml (there is also a larger bottle available to purchase), this spray provides a soft matte finish without dehydrating the skin.
- Up to 16 hours hold
- Similar formulation to the UD version
- Soft matte finish
- Slightly cheaper than Urban Decay
- Loved by makeup artists
- Slightly strong smell
- Contains alcohol which may not suit sensitive skin
The ELF Stay All Night Micro Fine Setting Mist is a budget-friendly dupe for the Urban Decay Setting Spray priced at $9/£10 for 80ml.
While it’s not an exact replica, it does offer similar benefits in terms of helping to prolong the wear of makeup and keeping it in place. The ELF mist helps to increase the longevity of makeup and it feels super lightweight on the skin.
The ELF Mist also contains aloe vera to soothe the skin, making it a good option for sensitive skin types.
- Provides up to 16 hours of wear on all skin types, including oily
- Boasts skin loving ingredients like aloe vera
- Feels more hydrating than the Urban Decay setting spray
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Contains fragrance
- Some people don’t like the nozzle (I personally find it works fine)
The Nyx Matte Finish Setting Spray is a popular dupe for the UD All Nighter since it helps to keep makeup in place all day without making the skin look too shiny.
This is another great budget-friendly option, priced at $9.50/£8 for 60ml. The super fine mist keeps makeup in place or up to 8 hours and controls shine for a matte finish. Similarly to the UD version, this NYX setting spray contains alcohol.
- Provides up to 8 hours of wear for oily skin
- Provides a matte finish
- Contains niacinamide to help minimize pores
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Small bottle (although a maxi size is available)
- Not as long-lasting as other setting sprays
The Revolution Professional Oil Control Fixing Spray is a brilliant budget option for those wanting a matte complexion. At $8/£6.99 for 100ml, this is one of the most affordable setting sprays on the market.
Like Urban Decay, this spray includes aloe vera to soothe and calm while holding makeup in place for up to 12 hours.
- Stops makeup melting on oily skin
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Doesn’t feel heavy
- Dries fast
- Unpleasant smell
- Not good for dry skin types
Maybelling Lasting Fix Matte Finish Makeup Setting Spray (Facestudio)
Another good budget dupe for the Urban Decay Setting Spray is the Maybelline Lasting Fix Matte Finish Makeup Setting Spray, priced $9.99/£9.99 for 100ml is an alcohol-based formulation that gives a matte finish.
It keeps makeup in place without smudging or fading.
- Up to 16 hour hold
- Fine mist spray
- Feels a little drying
- Strong smell
The L’Oreal Infallible Magic Setting Spray Mist is a great option for those who want a long-lasting setting spray that won’t break the bank.
Priced at £10.99 for 100ml, it gives a matte finish to lock makeup in place throughout the day or night. Another alcohol based setting spray that’s ideal for combination to oily skin types.
- Keeps makeup looking fresh throughout the day
- 100ml spray bottle
- Doesn’t feel dry or sticky
- Transfer proof
- Not widely available online
- Not cruelty-free or vegan
Best for Visible Pores:
The Morphe Mattifying Continous Setting Mist costs $17/£18 for 2.8oz (around 82ml).
This fine setting spray sets makeup for up to 12 hours, providing a fresh, matte finish to your complexion. Great for oily skin types, this spray contains nicinamide to help reduce pore size, and a range of fruit extracts to help control shine.
- Helps makeup to stay in place on oily skin types
- Has a nice watermelon scent
- Fine mist that doesn’t feel heavy on the skin
- Provides a smooth finish
- The nozzle becomes clogged easily
- Contains fragrance
The No7 Stay Perfect Matte Fixing Mist is £14.95 for 100ml, giving a velvet matte finish while minimizing pores and controlling shine. Formulated with niacinamide and alcohol, this setting spray is ideal for those with combination to oily complexions with visible pores.
- Fine spray that minimizes shine and pores
- Keeps makeup in place with minimal touchups
- Doesn’t look powdery
- Doesn’t feel tight
- Not completely transfer-proof
- Contains alcohol
Best for Touchups:
Sephora Collection Makeup Setting Spray delivers a 16 hour hold to keep makeup looking fresh. Priced $13/£14.99 for 80, this setting spray is also alcohol based like the Urban Decay spray, however, it also contains ginseng root to energize.
Transfer-proof, this spray is super fine to keep makeup in place without looking patchy.
- Holds makeup without clogging pores
- Can be used for touch-ups
- Feels lightweight on the skin
- Smells lightly of alcohol
- Can feel drying
The Milani Make It Last Setting Spray is ideal for oily skin types since it helps to control oil and keep makeup looking fresh all day. Priced $12.99/£14.50 for 60ml, this fine mist can be used to prep your skin, set it, and refresh it during the day.
This is an alcohol-based setting spray that also contains fragrance so it may not be suitable if you have sensitive skin.
- Keeps makeup in place for up to 16 hours
- Feels light on the skin
- Contains niacinamide to minimize pores
- Nice scent that isn’t overpowering
- The spray bottle isn’t the best
Best for Zero Shine:
Beauty Bay Set It Don’t Regret It Setting Mist, $13/£11 for 118ml is a mattifiying mist that keeps makeup in place for up to 12 hours. The weightless setting spray is alcohol-based to reduce shine and prevent makeup from melting.
- Great for oily skin types
- Vegan and cruelty-free formulation
- No stickiness or tight feeling
- Feels lightweight
- Not ideal for dry or sensitive skin types
Best No Fragrance Dupe:
The Kryolan Fixing Spray is £10.80 for 75ml or £24.60 for 300ml is used by many film and television makeup artists to create an invisible hold over makeup.
Although is meant to be used in combination with wet products, it does an excellent job of keeping all makeup in place, especially on oily skin types. While providing a similar hold to Urban Decay, the Kryolan Fixing Spray doesn’t contain fragrance.
- Great for oily skin types
- Water and smudge proof
- Can feel a little heavy
- Strong smell
Alternative Setting Sprays By Urban Decay for Dry, Sensitive, and Mature Skin Types
The Catrice Prime and Fine Multitalent Fixing Spray is $8/£4.99 for 50ml. This lightweight and quick drying spray is alcohol free, making it an excellent choice for dry to sensitive skin types.
It holds makeup in place, and can be used to prime and touch-up makeup too. As one of the most affordable setting sprays at the drugstore, this is great value for money.
- Good for all skin types
- No alcohol
- Feels lightweight and refreshing
- Ideal for travel
- Small bottle
Urban Decay Setting Spray Dupes: The Best Alternatives
Now you know the best Urban Decay setting spray dupes and alternatives on the market, you can find a cheaper or more suitable option for your skin type.
Discovering a high-quality dupe for Urban Decay’s iconic setting spray is a great way to save some money without compromising on performance. I’ve uncovered several impressive alternatives that offer similar benefits and results at a fraction of the price.
From the NYX Matte Finish Setting Spray to the Milani Make It Last Setting Spray, there are plenty of options available if you’re seeking a reliable setting spray dupe. These products not only effectively lock in your makeup for extended wear but also provide a refreshing mist that keeps your skin looking fresh and flawless throughout the day.
Remember, while Urban Decay’s setting spray has earned its reputation as a holy grail product, it’s always worth exploring alternative options that can deliver comparable results.
So, whether you’re a budget-conscious makeup lover or simply curious to try something new, don’t hesitate to experiment with these Urban Decay setting spray dupes. Discovering the perfect alternative might just become your new beauty secret, allowing you to achieve a flawless look every time.